Fresh Choice

8697 San Ysidro Ave, Gilroy, CA 95020, United States
$$$
(522 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

If you’re seeking a delightful dining experience that celebrates fresh flavors without breaking the bank, look no further than Fresh Choice in Gilroy, California. Nestled at 8697 San Ysidro Ave, this restaurant offers a unique buffet-style dining atmosphere that is as inviting as it is nourishing. With an all-you-can-eat price of just $17.99, Fresh Choice delivers incredible value for those who crave a variety of delicious options.

The restaurant specializes in an enticing array of Asian-inspired dishes, alongside a multitude of other beloved buffet staples. Guests can dig into hearty favorites like Kung Pao Chicken, featuring tender pieces of spicy stir-fried chicken mixed with peanuts, chilies, bell peppers, and zucchini, all infused with authentic Asian flavors. To complement this, the Vegetable Chow Mein is a delight, bringing together an abundance of fresh vegetables stir-fried in a savory sauce, making it a wonderful option for both vegetarians and meat-lovers alike.

The dining experience at Fresh Choice is marked by its fresh ingredients and attentive service. Diners rave about the vast salad bar teeming with crisp greens and vibrant toppings, along with an assortment of dressings that cater to every palate. According to a satisfied customer, “If you don’t want any of the premade dressings, they have olive oil and balsamic.” The salad bar is thoughtfully complemented by additional offerings like a baked potato bar and tempting nacho bar, ensuring that everyone leaves satisfied.

For dessert lovers, the temptations continue with delectable ice cream options drizzled with nuts and chocolate syrup, providing a sweet ending to any meal. Customers have described the muffins, especially the carrot flavor, as “superb,” and employees are known for their friendliness and dedication to making your visit unforgettable. One reviewer poignantly noted, “It’s not just the style choice, but the food experience is outstanding, especially the Spanish dishes.”

As the last standing location of its kind, Fresh Choice embodies a beloved legacy in the community. Reviewers frequently highlight the consistency of the offerings and the homely feel of the restaurant, making it a cherished dining destination for both locals and visitors alike. Whether you’re gathering with friends or enjoying a casual meal with family, Fresh Choice provides an environment that feels not just like eating out— it feels like coming home.

So next time you find yourself in Gilroy, take a trip to Fresh Choice, where wholesome food and a warm atmosphere await. With a perfect blend of variety and affordability, this restaurant ensures that every bite is a celebration of fresh, vibrant flavors.

522 Reviews
E Lee

27 Aug 2025

For the price, you can’t really complain. Salad greens were fresh. If you don’t want any of the premade dressings which are a bit rich, they have olive oil and balsamic. There are servers for the hot food and ice cream. I liked the roasted chicken legs and Chile verde. There was also 3 types of pizza, 8 soups, 4 muffins (carrot was my favorite), a baked potato bar, and a nacho bar. Sitting on the back patio felt better than inside. There were multiple families sitting inside.

Skip Pelton

07 Aug 2025

This was our first time eating here at this Fresh Choice, which I am being told that this is the last open buffet style fresh choice, which I didn’t know. This restaurant is independently owned which once you’ve come inside, you can easily tell that. It’s not the style choice, but I thought it was an extremely good experience the food outstanding especially the Spanish dishes. All of employees were quite friendly and very accommodating. The soda machine wasn’t working, but they accommodated us with a freshly brewed picture of iced tea and some kind of Kool-Aid/raspberry iced tea. That was really good. The American dishes could use a little more seasoning, but they provide you with a lot of extra seasonings and hot sauces which are more than fix that. If you’re visiting Gilroy and you’re looking for a good restaurant quality food at a reasonable price this is a place you should try out my wife and I really enjoyed it.

Yoke Lan Sun

03 Aug 2025

Nice! Salad bar has a lot of choices. Nacho cheese dip was very yummy. Also loved the Mac and cheese. Good healthy food at wallet friendly prices! I recommend everyone who loves salad to come here. You will be back for more!

Ashley Rajiv

16 Jul 2025

I went here my friends for dinner and we had a great meal. The salad buffet spread were very fresh with lot of options available. All the salad dressings and sides were superb! Love their pizzas, muffins and ice cream drizzled with nuts and chocolate syrup!

Jimmy Fung

02 Jun 2025

It looks the same as it did over 5 years ago. Food was still fresh and it was sad to hear it is the last location left. Great to see that they now have meat items like the BBQ style chicken, which was tasty. The baked goods were quite good especially when it came out fresh. Corn bread, brownie, and fresh bread aas good. Nacho bar was new and they had the pasta bar and pizza as I remember. No more soft serve but they had scoop vanilla ice cream. Fruit and puddings for dessert bring back memories with my kids. Staff was friendly and helpful and that made it nice on the quiet Monday when we went. They still made new food with about an hour and a half till closing. We will be stopping by again the next time we are in town.

Join the Fresh Choice Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.